“This haunting phantasmagoria of a film—comic, singular, surreal—is not only something no one but the Canadian director could have made, it’s also a film no one else would have even wanted to make. Which is the heart of its appeal.
[...]
It’s part and parcel of the unexpected charm of “My Winnipeg” that it is all but impossible to tell which of these things is real and which is the product of Maddin’s eccentric imagination. The director, however, is so adept at weaving his spell, you don’t even care. “My Winnipeg” is a film to give yourself to, with pleasure.”
--Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles Times Movie Critic, reviewing Guy Maddin’s My Winnipeg.
And IFC First Take described it as a “...deliriously layered provocation,” “outrageous, informative and wildly entertaining.”